Thursday, December 19, 2024

Sudan Tribune

Plural news and views on Sudan

The killing of kids is not only a crime but a sin

By Zechariah Manyok Biar

October 12, 2009 — I have been waiting to hear how people from Dinka Bor would react to the killing of seven Kuku children by armed Bor civilians in their ongoing fight against armed Mundari civilians. To my delight, many people from Bor community who commented about the incident condemned the killing of these innocent children. One comment that really caught my attention and even compelled me to write this article was from Gai Kuol Deng who is also from Bor. Although Gai mentioned a killing of children in Pariak by Mundari few months ago, he condemned the killing of the innocent seven children in Gemeiza in the strongest term he could think of. Gai said under the article published by Sudan Tribune, entiled, “7 children killed in Dinka Bor fresh attack at Gemeiza,” “The killing of kids is not only a crime but a sin.”

I cannot add more to Gai’s use of terms in condemning the killing of these innocent children. Killing is only justified if it is between the armed people. In our culture in the South, in almost all our communities, the killing of children, women, and old people is unacceptable. We did not need human rights laws to understand that these groups of people were no threat to anybody during any fighting because they could not attack anybody. Why would one kill them?

I thought our people in Bor were going to be blindfolded by their tribal loyalty at the expense of what our community upholds as the right thing to do—not killing innocent people. But I am happy that many people from Bor still know that it is unacceptable to kill children however much one is provoked.

I am also happy to hear that the Governor of Jonglei State Gen. Kuol Manyang Juuk has visited the scene of the fighting in Mundari areas where the recent fighting destroyed Mundari villages and displaced its people.

I am further happy that Governor Kuol “has ordered the commander in charge of the Dinka Bor cattle camps to move all the camps into Jonglei state within seven days,” as reported by Sudan Tribune on October 11, 2009, whatever that means. Commander in charge or the chief of cattle camps? I don’t know.

We want to see if the armed youth from Bor will disregard Governor Kuol’s orders the same way Lou-Nuer youth disrespected Deputy Governor of Jonglei State Mar’s advice last month and still attacked Duk Padiet. We will wait and hear what happens within seven days that Gov. Kuol has given as the deadline for moving out of Bor cattle camps from Gemeiza areas. It doesn’t matter whether Gov. Kuol is not in direct control of youth chiefs in cattle camps, our people still understand that Gov. Kuol is the Governor of Jonglei State and has direct authority to order any local leader in Jonglei State to move away from any place deemed problematic. This is what we expect our leaders to do. Leaders who side with their tribes against other tribes do not deserve to be our leaders. Our message as citizens of South Sudan must be clear in this area.

We know that sometimes people are provoked to act, but we must maintain our values in any situation. We must respect the lives of innocent people even when their fathers and their husbands were the ones who provoked us. Two wrongs do not make right. We cannot justify the killing of innocent people in any community simply because their people killed our innocent people in the near past.

I would conclude by saying that I am proud about the comments many people from Bor gave against the killing of the seven innocent children from Kuku. We must add to this maturity and teach our people what it means to respect the lives of innocent people in any situation. Not only the lives of children, women, or old men that we regard as innocent in our culture, but we must also teach our people to respect the lives of captured people during the war because captured people are always helpless and they become no threat to anybody when they are in the hands of their enemies. South Sudanese are not enemies among themselves. We must know that our disagreements always are at the level of brothers and sisters even if these disagreements lead to loss of lives.

Zechariah Manyok Biar is a graduate student at Abilene Christian University, Texas, USA. He is pursuing a Master of Arts in Christian Ministry and a Master of Science in Social Work, specializing in Administration and Planning. For comments, contact him at email: [email protected]

21 Comments

  • Lado
    Lado

    The killing of kids is not only a crime but a sin
    This killing of kids is attributed to Nuer who have no senses.
    DinkaBor could not abandon their well respected culture of restrain and copy Nuer attitudes.
    Atleast this killing could have been justified on the ground of culture had it been carried out by Nuer.

    It has surprised us the Equatorian how the Bor could imitate Nuer culture of barbaric acts.

    Please please Bor stick to your culture and stop revenging on the kids.

    Reply
  • Akol Liai Mager
    Akol Liai Mager

    The killing of kids is not only a crime but a sin
    Thanks Manyok Biar for adding your voice to Gai Kuol, two thousand petition voices are needed now to encourage those killers to voluntarily surrounder themselves to the Police and plea their guilty in front of justice.

    Encouraging those killers to come forward will not only comfort the grieving families, it will actually make Non-Bor Jaang (Dinka) believe the values and norms that you expressed in this article are true and exist.

    Once again, thank you for your condemnation Article.

    Reply
  • Mr Famous Big_Logic_Boy
    Mr Famous Big_Logic_Boy

    The killing of kids is not only a crime but a sin
    A dog never understand how bad she/he is making a big loss to an innocent chicken. the same to those mad, poor, crab and ugly dogs doesn’t know their own foolishness. Only God will judge.In addition we know the solution to them, just blocking foods from Equatoria will solve the problems. Starving to grave will come to their ugly faces.

    Reply
  • Wani Wonyoro
    Wani Wonyoro

    The killing of kids is not only a crime but a sin
    I wish all Southerners were like the Israelites who are just one big tribe with only one common enemy the Palestine.
    The death of one Israelite is always mourned by the whole Nation and it is the concern of all citizens to find the route course of the problem, thoroughly investigated and appropriate measures are taken against those involved by the concerned authority.

    We really do not love our nation and the spirit of patriotism is not in us. We claimed to be true christians who read and understand the Bible well and it is nowhere in the ten commandaments where killing of fellow human being is justified but instead all Christians are obligated to love their enemies and do good to those who wrong them.
    Our work is to preach love, peace and unity but not enemity as many of us are doing regarding the ongoing clashes.
    We are not different from the Pharisees of those days whom Jesus called Hypocrites because thier teachings were not inline with thier deeds.
    I really wonder why we celebrate when we see our fellow brothers and sisters dying without any cost. Let us not only learn to be sympathetic but Pathetic as well.

    Reply
  • John Garang Ajak
    John Garang Ajak

    The killing of kids is not only a crime but a sin
    Thank you Manyok, for condemning this repulsive act of killing innocent children. However, I agree with Gatwech on the fact that the case has not been investigated. We are not sure if this sadistic act was carried out by Bor-Dinka. Quoting Lado, “Bor-Dinka could have not dispose of their well respected culture of restrain and copy Nuer approach”. I am not calling Nuer out on this issue for they have nothing to do with this particular incident but just quoting Lado.

    Manyok, as you should know Bor-Dinka has been attacked numerously by their neighboring communities; they have had children killed in the same fashion but not once have Bor revenge these wicked act. They are the hinge of southern Sudan going eye for an eye is not in their interest. In fact, it looks like their reluctance to take revenge has been misconstrued by their neighbors. Communities in the greater Jonglei are beating their chest thinking that Bor’s lenience is a sign of weakness but it just doesn’t benefit us southerner if we all resorted to the habit of intolerance. We have a lot on our plats at the moment; the enemy is beating the dram of victory for they have found the greater weakness in us. We have a lot to think about compatriots. My heart goes out to the parents of the children murdered in Gemeiza.

    John Garang Ajak( Pennsylvania,USA)

    Reply
  • Dinka Boy
    Dinka Boy

    The killing of kids is not only a crime but a sin
    To all Southerners,

    Killing is immoral standard;therefore, no an individuals in history like the act of killing. But in most Southerners tribe like such as Nuer, Mundari, and murley, its the cheapest and beautiful exercise in their societies.

    In fact, we all must understand that those kinds of act( Killing) are now being adapted by peaceful tribes like Dinkas in general leave alone Dinka-Bor.

    Frankly, i never ever heard since i was born that Dinkas like or encouage the killing of children. My friends, if you kill achild, then you really disgrace your credibilty in society and that is why we condemned the killing of innocents. Example, when there fight a mong us cildren, women, oldpeople remained home, and even though foe get them they don,t killed them.

    According to Dinka societies, they fear the killing of Women, children(boys and girls), oldmen, and the don,t burn houses, storages, foods,and among others.

    Nuer burns Duk- padiet houses last month, Nuer killed incents civilians in 1992- oldmen and women, and childrens. Nuer burn SPLM administration in Duk and killed innocent guards, likewise Murle and Mundari did the above immoral acts.
    Dear brothers i don,t hide things for the sake of its,but i tell the truth.

    The above immoral acts where learned from Nuer and Murle acts.
    Anway, i don,t like the killing of children,but if my innocents are killed then that will be the better path to followed.
    Thanks

    Reply
  • thieleling
    thieleling

    The killing of kids is not only a crime but a sin

    Uncle Luk Dak,

    Please don’t always bring things that are done by non-Nuers back to Nuer people on this website. The killing of innocent Equatiria children was done by Dinka-Bors, but not Nuers. The Nuers are really dis-heartened by this sadistic & criminal act by fellow south sudanese.

    If you have a special relationship with Dinka-Bors or “Ustaz Manyok Biar” as you called him or simply trying to appease him/them on what Bors did against the people of Equatoria, please don’t do this on the expense of the Greater Nuer People’s name.

    The Greater Nuers “eat from what they cultivate” on their lands in Nuerland. They work hard on their own lands & therefore are not interested in grabbing Equatoria lands like what is happenning between the Dinka-Bors & Equatorians. this is what leads to the recent killing of innocent children by Dinka-Bors in mundariland.

    Condemn this act of its own nature as it is cowardic & immoral act by men against the children of south sudan from Equatoria. Please, please uncle Luk, I urge you knowing your age to forfeit the caricature of the Nuer image & name for whatever reasons best known to you. I do respect you as could be respected elder in Nuerland.

    Please forgo whatever you have against the Nuers and instead, focus on sincerety, fairness and honesty as one of the elders in sudan. If you want to be fair, you could have list, Pibor, Duk, Akobo, Numule, Torkech, Rumbek, Kuacjok, recent killing in Mundariland & so many others across south sudan. Why only Torkech & Duk? Why this unfair prejudice uncle Luk against the Nuers?

    Reply
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *