Home | Comment & Analysis    Friday 2 March 2012

The Myth of South Sudan


By Makol Bona Malwal

March 1, 2012 — South Sudan was conceived on the myth that we are one people with one common destiny. We are now discovering that regional and tribal differences are not dissolving and that South Sudanese think and act very differently from one another.

The simple fact is that people who are raised thinking of their tribe/ nationality as Pojulu, Dinka, Shuluk, Zande, Bari, Murle, Nuer, or what have you will probably always think of themselves in that way. It may take several generations for the concept of being Pojulu, Dinka, Shuluk, Zande, Bari, Murle, Nuer, or what have you to become the equivalent of being a New Yorker or Californian to an American, and those generations will be longer than generations were in the USA in the 1800s.

It is very important that we highlight the possible challenges and the inconsolable pains to face South Sudan beyond the passionate emotions for independence and try to stimulate the start of thinking rationally for all our future’s sakes. Our new country will face many challenges, despite simplistic categorizations of our war of independence as being between Africans and Arabs/ Christians versus Muslims. South Sudanese are not a unified group; this is a profoundly & proudly multi-ethnic, multi-racial and multi-religious lot/ land.

Any sense of a common national identity that does exist was forged in the struggle against the Mundukuro (north Sudan), something that we are all acutely aware of.
The point is that South Sudanese must ask themselves if a ’South Sudanese Nation’ is, in fact, truly what they want. A true nation of South Sudanese will require the majority of its citizens to share common values, common ideals, common mores, and most likely a common language.

If these do not exist naturally, they must be cultivated and that leads to some very difficult ground for debate and discussion (and the potential for many, many problems). As part of this, South Sudanese must ask themselves why they want a South Sudanese Nation. Is it to compete economically with the Mundukuru (north Sudan), East Africa, and other large population economies (a really bad reason to build a nation)? To prevent any possibility of another grand South Sudanese civil war (South Sudan imploding)? Or why?

This lack of unity is South Sudan’s most profound crisis, one that underlies the country’s economic and political woes. Most South Sudanese have little idea what the country stands for, what binds its people together, where it has come from in the past, and where it is going to in the future. After decades of war and a hefty (and still growing) death toll, we have succeeded in attaining independence without gaining a nation.

Yes, but what is a South Sudanese?

Values matter because they are the glue that binds countries and peoples together. They help define what a society stands for and against. There is no consensus within South Sudan or among South Sudanese, not even the beginning of a consensus, about what South Sudanese values are.

Diversity does not equal tolerance and the existence of differences does not mean acceptance of them. A fact that has come glaringly to the fore as South Sudan has slipped deeper into crisis and relationships have strained among its people and tribes.

The relationship between peasant communities and pastoralists with shared livelihoods need to be effectively managed or else violence is the natural outcome of mismanagement.

One can of course have multiple identities. Some Europeans are Catalan and Spanish, as well as European. But identities cannot be artificially created; they are forged early on and never go away. We must construct common institutions, laws and create all the symbols of a nation-state. Prosperity for a war-torn country, freedom from tyranny and peace among our people & tribes after decades if not centuries of bloodletting should be some of the ideals we should aspire too.

This is not to say that a united South Sudanese Nation will never happen, but it must be understood that it will be a long, slow process and will likely be longer and slower than the process was in the US for example, due to a longer legacy of conflict between our tribes & people and of all things longer life-spans of those generations today that think of themselves as coming from specific tribes rather than being South Sudanese.

Over the long term though, people need the solace and sense of community and shared culture, history and custom that nationhood provides.

Makol Bona Malwal can be reached at: mbmalwal@yahoo.com

The views expressed in the 'Comment and Analysis' section are solely the opinions of the writers. The veracity of any claims made are the responsibility of the author not Sudan Tribune.

If you want to submit an opinion piece or an analysis please email it to comment@sudantribune.com

Sudan Tribune reserves the right to edit articles before publication. Please include your full name, relevant personal information and political affiliations.
Comments on the Sudan Tribune website must abide by the following rules. Contravention of these rules will lead to the user losing their Sudan Tribune account with immediate effect.

- No inciting violence
- No inappropriate or offensive language
- No racism, tribalism or sectarianism
- No inappropriate or derogatory remarks
- No deviation from the topic of the article
- No advertising, spamming or links
- No incomprehensible comments

Due to the unprecedented amount of racist and offensive language on the site, Sudan Tribune tries to vet all comments on the site.

There is now also a limit of 400 words per comment. If you want to express yourself in more detail than this allows, please e-mail your comment as an article to comment@sudantribune.com

Kind regards,

The Sudan Tribune editorial team.
  • 2 March 2012 10:04, by Paul Ongee

    M.Bona Malual,

    The first line of the sixth paragraph has summed up the whole issue of unity that’s why the leadership of SPLM/SPLA has been consistently appealing to the South Sudanese masses. However, going to Khartoum for food and positions was the main cause of disunity among southerners which didn’t reflect the popular uprising of 1955 that SPLA/SPLM has achieved today......

    repondre message

    • 2 March 2012 10:05, by Paul Ongee

      If a family of any tribe in South Sudan can iron out any differences, what about southerners? The same thing happened in US history, the Southern Confederate States of US were for British and against the Independence of USA. See now how they are all proud to be Americans because of the true liberation leadership of George Washington. During the war of 1860s, defections happened but without......

      repondre message

      • 2 March 2012 10:06, by Paul Ongee

        .....significant impact because British were oppressing the New World/USA.

        repondre message

        • 2 March 2012 10:19, by Mi diit

          Political disunity in South Sudan began with kokora between Abel Alier and Joseph Lagu in 1980s. This was repeated in 1983 between John Garang and Samuel Gai Tut. Terming it as simply going to Khartoum for food shows how little your brain is.

          repondre message

          • 2 March 2012 12:48, by Ruach

            Who are Pojullu? what did they do? Oh may be they are pple with Juju and kill themselves and that is why u can somthing which seems like one household is called as a tribe in Equatoria.Stop your stupid thinking that you are better than any other tribes in South Sudan interms of Education

            repondre message

          • 2 March 2012 21:35, by LL Reuben

            Midiit (Gat-witch),

            Paul is right, Southeners disunity was started by power-hungry individual and the massese who attached themselves to them so they can be fed with food. Brain can’t be small when the truth is being told. You and your co have all the tools just do what you can to redeem yourself. Otherwise, don’t take insult when others don’t mean to be ignorant but just being realistic.

            repondre message

    • 3 March 2012 00:27, by Jimmy A. Makur

      Thanks for invaluable article and concerns about our nation. Yes of course there is no nation which can be builded by tribes.

      It is hard for both of the conflicts to come to good term with one another if people involves don’t admit their wrong doings.

      The only way forward is to find those few nationalists and peace lovers and give them a chance.

      repondre message

  • 3 March 2012 04:58, by Elijah B. Elkan

    Mr. Malwal,

    The title of your article "The MYTH of South Sudan" is extremely negative. Do you have problem with south Sudan independence?. Would you like to remain under the imbeciles of Khartoum. Mr. Malwal you need to address the concerns and how to unite the citizen of the south Sudan with a common language wish is of course English.

    repondre message

Comment on this article

The following ads are provided by Google. SudanTribune has no authority on it.

Sudan Tribune

Promote your Page too

Latest Comments & Analysis

Completion of 2nd GERD’s filling necessitates a shift in trilateral negotiations 2021-07-20 19:55:28 By A.Tesfaye Abera The completion of the second-year filling of the Great Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD) instigates polarized views between Ethiopia, Sudan and Egypt. Mainly Egypt sees it as (...)

South Sudan legislators should be cautious about the oath they will take 2021-07-15 07:04:56 By Roger Alfred Yoron Modi It is a fact that the legislators of South Sudan’s incoming Reconstituted Transitional National Legislative Assembly (TNLA) are appointees of the parties to the (...)

What they said about Sudanese John Garang 2021-07-12 05:49:37 By Mahmoud A. Suleiman This article of a compilation of related topics comes against the backdrop of a number of issues relating to the Republic of South Sudan that was declared its inauguration (...)


Latest Press Releases

S. Korea supports UN communities building resilience project in Sudan’s Blue Nile 2019-09-09 09:26:41 UNDP Sudan September 5, 2019 (KHARTOUM) - An agreement was signed on 5th of September between the Korean Ambassador, His Excellency. Lee Ki-Seong and Dr. Selva Ramachandran, Resident (...)

Sudanese lawyers and Human rights defenders back calls for civil rule 2019-04-26 10:22:06 Press statement by 55 Sudanese lawyers and Human rights defenders on Sudan Sit-in and Peaceful Protest Khartoum -24/04/2019 We, the undersigned (55) Sudanese lawyers and human rights defenders, (...)

South Sudan’s Lafon youth condemn killings of civilians by Pari community 2019-04-03 21:54:29 Press Statement on the Fighting between Pari/ Pacidi and Lotuko/Lokiri on 24/3/2019 Release by The Lafon County Youth Union: We, the Lafon County Youth Union hereby condemn the atrocities and (...)


Copyright © 2003-2021 SudanTribune - All rights reserved.